Biogas Diagram – Jared Mummert

Social System       vs.           Ecosystem

Module2JDM5805

People’s basic need for food has indirectly lead to the destruction of forests in India. People need some source of heat to cook their food, and up until recently the only source for heat in India was to burn firewood. Collecting firewood wouldn’t be a bad source of energy if it were only needed for a small amount of people, but with India’s population nearing 1.25 billion and growing this problem is becoming more and more dire. The growing population could be thought of as a positive feedback mechanism for forest destruction, because a larger population means more firewood required to help heat the food for the people. As firewood becomes scarce, more children are needed to collect the wood. This is a runaway feedback mechanism, often described as positive feedback.

In comparing my diagram to figure 1.5 in the reading, you will notice that there are many similarities, and also some differences. In both diagrams you will notice that the arrows go both directions, meaning there are cases where the social system effects the environment and cases where the environment effects the social system. This makes up a landscape, described as the combination of environmental and human phenomena that coexist together in a particular place on Earth’s surface. The main difference is that the reading’s diagram considered the farm fields and irrigation water more than mine. There were similarities because we both based our diagrams off of the reading, and there were differences because each individual will have different things come to mind when reading something due to creative differences. By comparing the diagrams, I learned that there were some things that I should have included in mine that I left out, but there were also some things that I addressed that the reading’s diagram did not.

2 thoughts on “Biogas Diagram – Jared Mummert

  1. Hey Jared! My name is Caren Levin, feel free to check out my blog:
    http://geog030.dutton.psu.edu/2016/01/24/caren-levin-module-2/

    I really like how you organized your diagram so that it is very easy to follow and read. I completely agree with you about how the large population in India and their basic needs is indirectly leading to deforestation. Maybe one day, Biogas generators will become more accessible to everyone in India in order to stop this never-ending positive feedback loop. I noticed that both of our diagrams include children and how their progress in school is affected by working for their families through collecting branches and sticks. It’s important for children to receive an education and have time to do their schoolwork, so hopefully the increase in Biogas generators will decrease the number of children having to collect sticks for fires.

  2. Hi Jared,
    I think our diagrams have a lot in common. You can view mine at: http://geog030.dutton.psu.edu/2016/01/23/biogas-diagram-tanya-smith/

    I find it interesting that you think if there wasn’t such a high population it wouldn’t be such a big problem. Do you think over time, even with a smaller population, the same situation would result? It might take longer, but I think it would have been inevitable. I could be wrong, though. I think one of the biggest factors would be how long the trees need to regenerate, if the amount needed allowed the remaining to be stable. The other thing to look at, most likely the population will continue to increase. Like the reindeer mentioned in part of our readings. I don’t think there would be a tipping point for the population to cease any time soon. There really is a lot to consider!

Leave a Reply