Module 3-Maura McGonigal

Question 2.

In respect to the question do the ends justify the means; I think this is very situation based. There are cases where the sacrifice of the means is too much to justify the end result. There are also times where the means are a necessary evil to achieve the end. Both ethical ways of thinking exist because they both have merit and are needed for different situations. However, the decision of whether or not an action is justified depends on the individual analyzing the situation. Each individual has different experiences, which lead to different ethical beliefs. There are situations where one-person may believe that the end justifies the means but another individual may adamantly oppose the means to reach the end. As discussed in the module, this is why democracy is important. It is imperative that every individual has an opportunity to have their point of view represented in the governing body.

 

Question 6.

In regards to the question addressing selfishness and altruism, I personally believe that all lives are equal therefore my life is no more important or less important than any other individual’s life. I believe that every individual’s life is of equal importance. With that being said, I think it is important that each individual finds a balance in helping others and also focusing on their own success. Some individuals live an extremely altruistic life style that eventually wears on them and destroys their happiness, because they never take the time or energy to focus on their own happiness. On the other hand, some individuals live such a selfish lifestyle that they hurt and destroy the happiness of those that care about them. As with other ethical thought processes, I think that it is vital to find a happy medium between caring for others and caring for oneself. I believe that those who make themselves happy by ensuring the happiness of others achieve true happiness.

 

Question 4.

Question four presents a comparison of ecocentric ethics and anthropocentric ethics with regards to ecosystem’s purpose. Ecocentric ethics is a belief that ecosystems are most important and are what decisions should be made based on. Anthropocentric ethics is a belief system that humans are most important and the center of decisions. I believe that both belief systems are valid, but that neither is independently correct. I believe that both ecosystems and humans are important and are a deciding factor in decision-making and that a certain degree of balance between ecocentric and anthropocentric thought is necessary. With that being said, I believe that ecosystems existed long before humans walked this earth. I feel that ecosystems have their own purpose other than serving human needs; however, I recognize there is an overwhelming overlap between the two. As the population of humans increases, it is hard to find an ecosystem that humans do not utilize for their own purposes.

2 thoughts on “Module 3-Maura McGonigal

  1. Hello Maura, this is Wenjie Zheng. Your point about the democracy to justify means and ends really interest me. As I was answering this question, I feel like it is a very confusing about this sophisticated question. Progress can be a consequence and vice versa. As in your post, democracy is the ‘end’ to the ‘progress’ as how I interpreted. Democracy is also a progress to have people come up with ideas in the government.
    Maybe you can check out my response to this question:
    http://geog030.dutton.psu.edu/2016/01/31/m3la_wzz5097/

  2. Hi Maura I’m Will Graf. I read your post and I agree with a lot of your comments. My comments are direction mostly towards question 6 where you state that you see yourself the same as all other humans. I just believe that all humans want to feel that way, but it has been programmed in all humans to be selfish. This is why we have survived, and will continue to survive because we have been selfish. We feed off of the land and kill animals for food. Many of the times when we help others we do so to feel that happiness that you talk about in your post. This asks the question of is it selfish to do an unselfish act to feel that happiness? I am not saying that you are wrong, but I just think that all humans are programmed to be somewhat selfish. I really enjoyed reading your post and if you would like to read my post I have included the link below. Thank you!!!
    http://geog030.dutton.psu.edu/2016/01/31/lesson-3-william-graf/

Leave a Reply