Module 3 Ethics- Carmen Madrigal

1.) Is it more important to be a good person or to perform good acts (virtue ethics vs. action ethics)? This question made me think a lot because I personally think that in order for one to be a good person they must have role model characteristics to make them a great person. Although in my opinion, I have always believed that it is more important to be a good person, than to be someone who performs good acts. My reasoning behind my opinion is that anyone can perform a good deed, but it is hard to find a good individual. Another thing is most good people always perform acts of kindness because they mean it. I’d prefer someone who is sincere about doing something over someone who does it to do a good deed. In my personal view, I believe I am a good person because of my actions and the way I always try to reach out and do more for those that need the help. Your actions are never always seen, but first impressions are always important and if someone sees that you are a good person then it’ll take you further in life.

3.) Does the process by which decisions are made matter more than the outcomes of these decisions (procedural justice vs. distributive justice)? I felt as if this question made me think of where I would fall. I personally think that I fall in between, but tend to lean more towards decisions matter more when you think them through. The reason is that I have always been the kind to think ahead, although there have been times where I have acted without thinking. I know that even when you plan ahead sometimes the outcomes are not as you planned them out to be. I think that as much as one sits there on planning ahead rather the decisions is right or wrong, one can never really predict the outcome. I will have to say that it is better to think to thank to act without thinking because depending on whatever the case may be there could be consequences that could be prevented.

6.) Is my own life worth more than the lives of others, the same, or less (selfishness vs. altruism)? I believe that my life is valuable because you only get to live once, but I think that my life is the same as others. The reason why that is is everyone decides what to do with their life, so what someone makes out of it is on them. My parents have always told me, “treat others how you would like to be treated”, which has made me think that everyone is the same just with different ways of living. No matter what anyone says every life is valuable no matter where you come from or what your past may be. I have always believed that the more you do by heart the more that you will get out of life. In which, I have to say it has got me further in life and has made me the individual I am.

2 thoughts on “Module 3 Ethics- Carmen Madrigal

  1. Hi Carmen! My name is Julie! I noticed that we answered the same questions with the exception of question 3. Although I did not agree with your answer to question 1 in my blog, I rethought my answer to that question. I agree that sometimes people who perform good acts aren’t always the best of people. In that case, the good person would be better than one who does good acts. For question 6, I agree because I also answered that everyone’s lives matter no matter who they are. Finally, I was interested in your response for question 3 because many times we don’t know the outcome(s) of some decisions we make. That is why sometimes it is okay for outcomes to be bad because we can learn from these outcomes to make better decisions in the future.
    Here is a link to my blog post! http://sites.psu.edu/geog30/2016/02/02/ethics-views-julie-cardillo/

  2. Hi Carmen! I’m Cody, my blog post is located here http://geog030.dutton.psu.edu/2016/02/01/cody-rhodes-ethics/.

    I think that the actions of humans influence character, that is to say, our individual actions affect how we are perceived by our community. You say that being a good person is more important than performing good acts, but I offer that the two are intertwined. So speaking from an universal perspective I pose this question, is it ethical to adopt a anthropocentric course of action that our future generations may look with distaste upon our present character, lest our actions debilitate the environment so that we affect their ability to survive?

Leave a Reply