Module 3: Ethics

1. I believe that the actions a person takes are far more important than their particular virtues.  A person can say anything they want, but they will not be taken seriously if they do not follow what they say.  If a politician speaks about how pollution is a rising problem and must be stopped, yet continues to pass laws favoring high-pollution companies, most of the public won’t consider them an ecocentric person.  Likewise, if a person complains all day about how global warming is a huge issue, but continues to drive a gas-guzzling Hummer to work everyday, their words mean nothing.  However, this does not mean that virtues are not important.  Moral virtues are what, most of the time, lead to moral actions.  If a businessman truly does not believe that global warming is a real issue, he most-likely will not take any steps towards fixing it.  Virtue and action may go hand and hand, but what you think means very little if it is the opposite of what you do.

4. In my opinion, the ecosystem should matter more in the way it impacts humans rather than its own sake.  The first reading for this module consisted of a man trying convince an audience that a certain national park should not be turned into an energy-creating dam.  Although this article is very well written, I disagree with his main argument.  While the park may be a “grand” place, the benefits we can gain from building a dam a far too important to overlook.  The clean energy that a dam will provide can power almost an entire city,  which, in the long run, will end up helping the ecosystem.  This is just one example, however, I feel most situations like these should be looked at from an anthropocentric point of view.  If we pass up on opportunities to evolve and benefit as a species just to preserve nature,  we miss the chance to progress as humans.

5. I also believe that the pleasure and pain of humans is much more important than that of non-humans.  One of the reasons why humans are on top of (or even removed from) the food chain is because we learned to work together to get things such as food and warmth.  Ever since the beginning of our species, this will usually result in the death of other animals to be used as meat and/or clothing.  While we shouldn’t go out of our way to harm these other species, we also should not hesitate if we need to use them to benefit ourselves.  While a horse or a dog may still be able to suffer, it comes nowhere near close to the severity of a human-being, our own kind, being in pain.  Species sticking together is a natural part of life and while we shouldn’t go out of our way to make non-humans be in pain or suffer, we should still prioritize us over them.

3 thoughts on “Module 3: Ethics

  1. Hello, my name is Jake Segall. Here is a link to my post!

    http://geog030.dutton.psu.edu/2016/02/03/m3-your-ethics-views-jake-segall/

    I agree with your answer for question one, but the other two I have a slightly different view on. As many people do (this course being no exception), you have separated humans from the rest of the ecosystem. This decoupling of humans from the rest of what makes up the ecosystem is, in my eyes, the beginning of any issues that we face today. Instead, I see the two parts as one. We are shaped by the ecosystem just as we shape the ecosystem. In this sense, I believe it is important to keep the ramifications of anything done to the ecosystem in mind as they will ultimately reverberate through our lives.

    That is not to say you are wrong, and I am right. In some ways, I do agree with you. While I know a cow can feel pain and be afraid to lose its life, I still crave and eat beef. The benefits of meat to our society outweigh the negatives of killing cows at this point in our existence. This may change as the world ages.

  2. Great post! I totally agree with all three of your answers. I really like the way you worded the importance of the ecosystem, and I really support the fact that as bad as it is to develop the environment, it is necessary for our way of life right now. I wish there was a way to strike a balance, but as of right now I certainly don’t see one. Thanks for the great post, I look forward to reading your next one. Good luck!

Leave a Reply