Ethics Views – Sebastian Hollabaugh

1) Is it more important to be a good person or to perform good acts (virtue ethics vs. action ethics)?

In order to answer this question, the use of the word “important” needs to be defined. In general, being a good person is more important, because the good acts should come from a naturally good person based on their desire to want to be good. Thus being a good person covers both aspects. However, a bad person may choose to perform good acts based on societal values, while still not being a good person at heart. In this case it may be seen that performing good acts is more important in order to maintain social normativity, or advance the society in general. This bad person may not enjoy doing good acts, and may in fact do them for selfish reasons, such as to give off the appearance of being a good person. Regardless of the reason, the act of bad people performing good deeds, alongside all of the good people who inherently perform good deeds eventually helps maintain and advance society. There are obviously many counter arguments that could be applied here, but in general this is a universal idea that would hold true regardless of time period or place.

2) Do the ends justify the means (ends ethics vs. means ethics)?

For this question I would like to respond with another question. Would going back in time to kill Hitler as a innocent child be okay? You already know that he will start a genocide in the future, but at the time he hasn’t committed any crime. Would killing an innocent child for his future actions, just because you have a time machine (the means) be worth preventing the holocaust (the ends?). What if you were sent back with no knowledge of who he was, and were told that killing this child would help mankind? This question epitomizes the question of “does the ends justify the means.” There are many options to consider with it. Maybe someone else would rise up, and be worse than Hitler, and the ends you aimed for were actually worse than expected. There is no way to definitely know, but you just have to hope that the moral idea of preventing the holocaust is enough of an end to justify killing an innocent child. I personally believe that one must act ethically at all times, including in the means. There are always other options, and most would agree that killing a child is a very unethical action, which means a different way of achieving the end would need to be considered. Throughout history, there have been many arguments where people have made an unethical decision in order to provide an ethical outcome, but I truly believe there is always a right way to handle something, without compromising morals. This of course would differ from culture and time period, because humans develop different morals in different places and times, but for the most part I believe that the ends do not justify unethical means.

6) Is my own life worth more than the lives of others, the same, or less (selfishness vs. altruism)?

Life is completely about the meaning you bestow upon it. Logically that would mean my life is more important than others, because I work hard to give my life meaning to myself. The same goes for the meaning that my friends have to me. Thus based on this tiny scale, yes, my life means more than the life of others to me. On a larger scale, my life probably won’t have a significant affect the advancement of humanity, the same as most of the other 7 billion people currently living, as well as the majority of people who came before or will come after us. At this scale we are comparatively all the same. Thus, life’s individual worth falls to a matter of scale, and does not change relative to time period or place. Due to these aspects, I believe that all lives are actually equal, and to an extent one should be altruistic in order to improve the lives of everyone, but not at any great expense to themselves.

Getting to Know You: Sabrina Hecht

Hi everyone, my name is Sabrina and I am a sophomore student here at Penn State University Park.  I haven’t done much moving in my life and grew up in a town in central New Jersey called South Brunswick.  Since attending my last two years of high school in South Brunswick I have known that I wanted to pursue something within the arts.  After discovering graphic design as a career path, I knew that is what I wanted to do with my life.  I am now studying graphic design at Penn State and could not be happier.  Since I started studying graphic design, I realized how broad the field is.  Maps happen to be a big part of graphic design history and it is very interesting to me to learn about all of the different things I could possibly be running into throughout my life, geography being one of them.  Other than an interest and passion for graphic design I sometimes like to switch in between TED Talks and music in the background of my homework!

After reading through this first module the first issue I thought of that I believe geography can address is how the environment can affect the rate and amount of homeless people in a given territory.  The environment has created some drastic changes of how we live throughout history. It would be very interesting to understand the spatial scale of environmental catastrophes such as a hurricane so that I could understand just how much of an impact these kinds of disasters have on an issue such as the homeless.  Although I would assume that a disaster such as a hurricane has a concentrated area of which the people are affected I realize that those types of events can cause change in the surrounding areas as well.  It is important to understand how although some things may seem like it is only affecting a small number of people it could be the exact opposite.  I know that geography can study lots of issues that lead to chain reactions and I look forward to learning how to break down, understand and visualize the many relationships between human and environment.

M1_LearningActivity_wzz5097

I am Wenjie Zheng, a sophomore this year. Right now I live in State College, PA but I grew up in Beijing, China. My major is Economics, but I would also like Geography as my minor, even as my second major. I haven’t decided what to do as the future career, but it will definitely be related to what I am learning now. Currently the topic of sustainability is a hot issue, as it closely related to the future of all human beings, whether how long we are going to last on this planet, and how we are going to sustain that amount of time. It interests me that I want to answer all the observations I witnessed around me. One of my hobbies is travelling. So I always see the actions people deal with environment. For example Germany likes to China harshly regulates the use on plastic bags; as well as the detoured ferry route to avoid shallow water coral reefs in Fiji.

I would like to talk about the issue with Visualization from this module. Visualization is an important way for people to be familiarized with this world, and it is also one of the most crucial tools for people to learn an object. In this section it addressed the issue that the most common map of the world that people are most familiar with is actually inaccurate in depicting the size of each country, water area, and continents. In the video posted, the scientists mentioned the example of Greenland Africa. It seems the Greenland is the same size as Africa on the map but it is actually 14 times smaller than Africa. This is due to the rectangular distortion with the map. They then introduced the Peters Projection, in which more accurately describing the size and location of each land in a rectangular map. By simply looking at the maps without knowing the figures and data people are often biased with area of a particular land. Visualization such as maps should offer an accurate depiction rather than making the map ‘good looking’.

Getting to know me

I am Brian Peck, a 33 year old, married, father of two awesome boys (8 and ten months). I spent ten and a half years in the United States Marine Corps where I worked as an air traffic controller. I got out to start my own farm and food truck but ended up moving to State College to work at the airport and go to school instead! I was born in Grand Rapids, Michigan and spent my later growing up years in Dallas, Texas, where I enlisted into the Marine Corps. I am interested in the Agricultural department, I want to own my own farm and store/restaurant/butcher/what ever else I can think of! So I am pursuing knowledge in the Ag field and business management, or something like that! (I really have no idea what I’m doing!) This course meets some requirement of mine and it looks interesting, I really just want to learn a little bit about everything.

I never gave geography much thought until now and realize how much I have used it in the past. From planning operations and site selection for FARP’s (forward arming and refueling points) to reading maps and figuring scale and position for troop movement, utilizing different aspects of geography, perhaps in a skewed fashion but I have used it nonetheless. Watching the video “Powers of Ten” was interesting, and that was made in 77! can you imagine if they re-made that video today? scaling down to the cell in the blade of grass under the picnic blanket? that would be interesting.

I look forward to working through this class this semester, I think it will truly be interesting. Good luck to you all!